In for a penny, in for a watt
David Crigger/Bristol Herald Courier
Because the 29,300 pennies John Almany used recently to pay his Bristol Virginia Utilities bill weighed around 168 pounds, he holds a representative sample to show the photographer.
Published: March 8, 2009
Updated: March 12, 2009
BRISTOL, Va. – Rather than get upset about his $350 electric bill, John Almany found a unique way to pay it – in pennies.
Almany said he and his brother Gary came up with the idea in January. After finding enough banks to supply the pennies, Almany delivered more than 29,000 to Bristol Virginia Utilities.
“I thought I’d make light of the situation,” Almany said. “Everybody gets mad, but there’s nothing anyone can do about it.”
Their first challenge, Almany said, was finding that many pennies.
“I called some nearby banks to see if I could exchange cash for pennies,” Almany said. “We got all the way to the w’s in the phone book. One bank gave me $170 in pennies and the other $123.”
After trading in the cash, Almany and his brother spent about an hour removing the coins from the 50-cent rolls and dumping them into two large, black duffle bags.
That many pennies weighs about 170 pounds, so the two men worked to carry the duffle bags into BVU’s Lee Highway office.
“We pulled into BVU about 2 [p.m.] and took the bags of unrolled pennies to the pay counter,” Almany said. “To make my case better, I noticed a man just paid cash right before me. I laid my bill on the counter and told the lady, ‘Here is my bill and I’m here to pay every penny of it.’ ”
After about 20 seconds of silence, Almany then explained what that meant.
“She seemed shocked and told me, ‘We can’t take that.’ She said we’d have to wrap that up and repeated they couldn’t accept it. I asked her if she was refusing my payment and she said she wasn’t,” Almany said. “They said they didn’t have the manpower to count all those pennies and I said as much as BVU is billing its customers, they ought to have all the manpower they need.”
Brian Bolling, BVU’s vice president of customer service, declined to respond to questions about Almany and his payment.
In an e-mail, Bolling wrote that BVU has enacted a payment policy.
“With respect to coins used for said payment, the following restrictions are imposed to prevent overburdening of the cashier operations of BVU due to time and weight issues, which restrictions are reasonable and do not constitute a refusal to accept coins as legal tender,” Bolling wrote.
The policy includes acceptance of no more than $10 in unrolled coins, while rolled coins “of any denomination up to 20 rolls will be accepted for each dollar of any one payment to BVU.”
There are no limitations on paper money.
Almany said BVU employees held a prolonged discussion with supervisors before eventually accepting his coins. They then spent about two hours counting just $26.
“They brought the rest back up because they were getting ready to close,” Almany said. “The lady told me to come back Monday and they would count the rest.”
With his point made, Almany said he took the rest of the pennies to a coin machine, and paid the balance of his bill in larger forms of cash a few days later.
Was it worth the trouble?
“It was worth every penny,” Almany said.
| (276) 645-2532
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
I think this is hilarious. And to think BVU went to the extent of developing a payment policy in response to this. Wow…now that’s an expected allocation of resources from BVU…I would expect nothing less.
How can a company reject legal tender, anyway? Isn’t money…money?
It would be cool if EVERYONE just quit mailing their payments in and went to the Utility office when they were paying for electric bill and stood there in line with pennies to pay their $300-$400 utility bills!!! I still haven’t figured out what the reason for these Utility bills going up so much is for. Why are we having to pay so much?
My utility bill for last month was $300.00 and I have wood heat !!! It’s one thing right after another going up and it’s to the point where 90% of the American people can’t afford to live even the most simple life anymore.
Times are horrible right now.
I am all for a secondary electric company. A little competition to BVU would help us all.
I think we ought to elect them Mayor and Vice Mayor!
My husband has been without work for over 6 months. . . he would gladly count pennies for the utility board if they would hire him! It would help pay our electric bill.
EVERYONE IS SAYING POOR POOR CASHIER, IF ANYONE WOULD HAVE BOTHERED TO HAVE READ THE ARTICLE THE BVU EMPLOYEES HAD A PROLONGED DISCUSSION WITH SUPERVISORS THEN ACCEPTED THE PENNIES AND IT TOOK THEM TWO HOURS TO COUNT 26 DOLLARS. WELL BOOO WHOOOOOO I HELPED MY BEST FRIEND COUNT 176 DOLLARS IN PENNIES BECAUSE SHE LOST HER JOB AND COULDN’T AFFORD TO PAY 8.9 CENTS ON THE DOLLAR TO USE A COIN MACHINE SO AT LEAST THE PEOPLE AT BVU HAVE JOBS. THAT’S MORE THAN MOST PEOPLE HAVE AND I AM SURE IT WOULDN’T HURT ALL OF THE UTILITIES IN THE TRI TO COUNT SOME PENNIES. MOST OF THE CASHIERS ARE NOT FRIENDLY ANYWAY
Gosh I couldn’t quit laughing. This is such a practical idea! I applaud you!
This is great, I have thought about doing it but never followed through. But way to go guys. To those of you that are complaining about it…there are two local utilities that have to have armed guards protecting their cashiers because of violent outbursts by people paying their bills, is that what you would prefer.
I have to defend the cashier because he treated her in a very disrespectful way. It’s not her fault that his electric bill was so high. Did he stand there and smirk at her as she counted all those pennies? Did he laugh at her as she called her supervisor to see what the proper protocol was for accepting the money? I’ll bet she went home in tears that day. He should send her flowers and a note of apology. It wasn’t her fault.
Kudo’s Mr. Almany…and to the people that have had negative words…Have none of you ever had a childish thought? but I for one do not think it childish…he could have chose a much more violent way to prove his point…I think it was an expression of what most of us are feeling during a time of loss jobs, cut in pay/hours, wonderment of how we will pay our bills and feed our kids. And the “Poor” Cashier that had to count the money…she/he should feel blessed that they get to have a job and the hours to count pennies. The questioning if Mr. Almany and his brother has a job is not the point of his actions, whether they are currently employed, retired or in between employment does not change the feeling of being robbed. All of you that failed to see the point and even the humor in this really need to lighten up remove that stick up your butts makes walking around the rest of us much easier. Again, Mr. Almany you and your brother are my new heros!!!!


Advertisement