Board of Supervisors Delays Decision on Truck Stop Project

Board of Supervisors Delays Decision on Truck Stop Project
» 14 Comments | Post a Comment

ABINGDON, Va. – In a midnight vote, the Washington County Board of Supervisors unanimously delayed a decision on the truck stop project at Exit 24 in Meadowview until July 14.

Immediately before that vote, a motion to reject the Love’s Travel Center was defeated 4-3 with supervisors Jack McCrady, Tom Taylor and Dulcie Mumpower opposing the project.

“We’ve got a school with 700 students here, and a whole lot of traffic generated by that school,” Taylor said. “We have an obligation to protect those people.”

The other four, Paul Price, Odell Owens, Phil McCall and Kenneth Reynolds rejected the motion to kill the project – indicating that they are likely to vote in favor of the truck stop next month.

The board is required by its bylaws to vote on an affirmative motion before a project can be approved.

“We’re all concerned about children,” Price said. “I really feel ... that we’re a little bit using children. For the three and a half years I’ve been here, I’ve not heard one negative thing about this until a few weeks ago.

“If Sullivan County [Tenn.] gets this, then that $2 million a year [in revenue] goes to Nashville and not to Richmond,” Price said. Then, “that exit will never be improved until there’s something that forces improvement.”

At the end of the five-hour meeting, supervisors said they were delaying the final decision because they want to review an environmental study on the project.

Truck stop opponents said in interviews after the board’s vote that they take issue with the environmental study done by Love’s, to comply with highway requirements.

“An important question is whether or not an environmental impact study allows us to model how this development will change the air quality in and around Meadowview Elementary School,” said opponent Joe Lane.

Mumpower said the truck-stop issue is a two-edged sword.

“It’s hard to determine what the right thing is to do,” Mumpower said. “We’ve got a situation where there’s a need for jobs and there’s some people in the community that are asking that this happen and appears to be that a lot of the people don’t want it to happen.”

Before the votes, the supervisors listened to scores of people expressing those opinions, all of whom signed up to speak at the public hearing the board held on granting the re-zoning and special-exception permit necessary for Love’s to build the travel center at what is now a rural interchange.

The project has generated tremendous controversy because the proposed site is less than a quarter-mile from Meadowview Elementary School, the county’s largest elementary school, which serves a large low-income population.

Both the Washington County Planning Commission and the county’s school board oppose the project.

Among those who spoke Tuesday was Patricia Williams Bradford, who owns the property and spoke out publicly for the first time about her decision to sell her family’s farm to Love’s.

“There are people here who believe I am a disinterested, unconcerned owner of the property that Love’s is offering to buy and wants to place a truck stop on,” Bradford said. “I beg to differ.”

Born in a house in Meadowview but now living in Tennessee, Bradford said the state and federal highway departments slowly chipped away at the farm that belonged to her grandmother, near the school where her mother taught, and where her family lived for almost 100 years.

“When the Interstate was built in the 1960s, many acres were purchased from my farm at an unreasonably low cost,” she said, adding that the widening of Route 80 and the addition of more Interstate ramps took more and more land.

“My family has been at the mercy of the Interstate for three generations,” Bradford said. “As the property owner, I just want to be able to sell the land to a responsible company that has a responsible land-development plan. … Just as the Interstate was good for Meadowview and the county when it came in, Love’s will benefit the community.”

Her son, Roberts J. Bradford Jr., of Gray, Tenn., said he hopes the truck stop development will generate interest in future projects on property he holds on the other side of the Interstate.

A majority of those who spoke Tuesday were opposed to the project, though a substantial number spoke in favor.

Speakers offered petitions: more than 800 signatures of those opposed to the truck stop, said Link Elmore; and more than 200 signatures of those in favor, said Gene Copenhaver, who lives across the road from Meadowview Elementary School.

“My mama taught me there would always be folks coming down the road wanting to use what you’ve got, and they will be using the word Love,” said Barbara Kingsolver, of Meadowview, “but you need not take the first offer that comes along.”

Kingsolver said the truck stop would suddenly mean more strangers than residents in Meadowview.

Charlie Darnell, also of Meadowview, encouraged supervisors to approve the project. People should be able to buy gas and eat at McDonald’s without traveling to another town, he said.

Alan Lee, superintendent of schools in Washington County, reiterated the school board’s concerns: the risk of a hazardous chemical spill at the interchange, the potential health hazard of diesel exhaust, the danger of added traffic in an emergency; and the threat of predators and other undesirable individuals coming to the school.

Those in favor of the project touted the economic benefits it could bring to a community.

“We’re in a small town. We need this,” said Bonnie Wilcox, one of the most outspoken proponents of the project.

“We need to get businesses in this area. Look at all of the people that have no jobs. They have to live on welfare. Some people love it, but a lot of parents don’t. They would rather have a place to work and provide for their own families.”

| (276) 791-0701

Advertisement

 
View More: No tags are associated with this article
Not what you're looking for? Try our quick search:
 

Advertisement

Reader Reactions

Flag Comment Posted by heydude on June 12, 2009 at 7:29 am

The county could buy the property in question and back out like they did with the town on the ball fields down the road. ha ha

Flag Comment Posted by heydude on June 12, 2009 at 7:24 am

I don’t think the board of supervisors or the school board have a concern about a Chem. spill they are just using this as a excuse right now, if they did the Meadowview school would have never been built at this location, cause the interstate was there before the school. The danger is the same if they have a spill on the interstate in the exit 24 area you would still have to empty the school of it kids,teacher,employees. No differenc.

Flag Comment Posted by joe4040 on June 12, 2009 at 12:38 am

I have notice that a lot of comments have been deleted here. They all contain comments about Dulice Mumpowers and the School boards actions. Just because one person thinks it is inappropriate doesn’t mean it is. What happen to the Freedom of Speech. Please inform all of us as to why their comments were deleted.

Has anybody else notice that they were quite a few comments deleted?  What do you think about tri-cities.com controlling your speech and comments?

Maybe we should all move to topix.com where they don’t control you right to free speech.

Flag Comment Posted by peterbilt4me on June 11, 2009 at 6:37 pm

Radio Bill I hope you come to the meeting and bring that paper that you said you read about tom taylor and dulcie mumpower…I would like for you to present it to the board….if you dont want to I would be happy too…

Flag Comment Posted by Radio Bill on June 11, 2009 at 7:09 am

I was reading todays news and see that Dulcie and Tom Taylor can’t wait until July 14th meeting to get their licks in against the truck stop, and that is without seeing the study that Love’s will provide as requested by Supv Owens. Read that article as I posted a response there also that covers joe4040 hoping someone would run against her. There is two people running, Vernon Smith vs Dulcie and Joe Straen vs McCrady.  And they both are pro business orientated, business that will provide all types of jobs to meet the needs of our residents. The woman at the meeting the other night was almost in tears because she could not find a job and would gladly take a job at the truck stop to support her family. So lets not fall into the trap of saying people are crooks, instead use your vote in November and help them retire from the board. Even if that means helping in their campaign, or contribute a few dollars so that they can advertise as it is hard to beat someone already in office and has accumulated a lot support from their position of power. And yes if you have friends or relatives in those districts call them and urge them to vote for a new supervisor.. Actions can speak louder than words. We need jobs in this county!

Flag Comment Posted by peterbilt4me on June 10, 2009 at 10:35 pm

well you must be new in this game because I think i have explained this before….like last nite at the meeting….Exit 22 is considered industrial and a truck stop is considered a business….so then it cant go there by the zoneing commission rules…

Flag Comment Posted by heydude on June 10, 2009 at 9:36 pm

Why can’t everyone use common sense and just put the truck stop at the 22. It makes more sense since there are so many trucks coming through there. It dosn’t make much sense for them to get on the interstate at the 22 and get off two miles up the road for fuel.

Flag Comment Posted by Radio Bill on June 10, 2009 at 12:09 pm

What better answer to Barbara than the man that said his first love he married 36 year ago and still is married. What about the guy in response to moving the truck stop to exit 22, which do you want to kill, the kids or the old folk at 22. Then Kudos to the young people who spoke up. And for the those who spoke out about their kids getting asthma if the truck stop goes in all of them must be planning on moving when they get out of MES, because where do they go next? Glade Spring Middle School with a bigger truck stop just 1/10th of mile further away. But of course these same people protesting that would not think twice if the truck stop is built about stopping after school at to feed their kids at McDonalds. Bless my wife because she asked me if they were concerned about the health of their children who were some of them outside smoking? Or does cigs not cause any harm?  And for the man who Brags about Boone I think he needs to get his head on straight and quit campaigning to get into politics here. He said a contractor would never build a McDonalds if they knew it was next to a school. Was he not listening that Love’s has a working relationship with McDonalds Corp, which means that the local franchisee will be foaming at the mouth for a truck stop location. “opening your ears before your mouth may open your eyes” I think maybe at least four of the board members eyes are wide open.

Flag Comment Posted by peterbilt4me on June 10, 2009 at 10:50 am

Barbara Kingsolver sounds like she has been walking down that road for along time…but Charlie Darnell had a good comeback!! I did notice that all that opposed… had health care jobs,teachers,professers,even lawyers!!! Last I heard they require alot of money for their services…So whats wrong with the people that aren’t quite so educated getting min. wage jobs as long as we have a job??? Thats the problem with that emory bunch and lets not forget joe l. they have good jobs sitting behind a dest pushing a pencil…I think we all need to cut off Joe L.s PONYTAIL!!!!

Flag Comment Posted by commonsense on June 10, 2009 at 10:26 am

“It’s hard to determine what the right thing is to do,” Mumpower said.

Better ferret out the answer on what’s best.  That’s why each of the Supervisors are there…

Post a Comment(Requires free registration)

The commenting period has ended or commenting has been deactivated for this article.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement